3 Comments
User's avatar
Tom Kane's avatar

Ben, the Canadian figures link snowfall to deaths and infer the shovelling, so the sex difference may reflect who picks up the shovel more than any difference in the heart. Sudden hard effort in the cold lands on blood vessels that are already constricted, which is why the combination deserves more respect than either part alone. The pre breakfast heating result belongs beside it, since a two degree change in the room moving morning blood pressure is a cheap intervention with a plausible mechanism. Your clarification that twenty percent means 120 deaths where 100 were expected is the line most readers will need.

Dr Tom Kane

Ben Jones MD PhD's avatar

Hi Tom. Yes, you're right. That was the meaning of my tongue-in-cheek comment about chivalry not being dead!

Jan Hempstead, RN's avatar

I’m curious if having baseline hypotension and bradycardia still puts you at the same risk. My two cents about men vs women with shoveling is that women tend to go slower and take smaller amounts of snow.